1972 (7) TMI 8 - HC - Income Tax

Assessee earned a profit of Rs. 2, 54, 862 being the appreciation in the exchange value of the price in dollars in terms of the Indian rupee - Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case the Appellate Tribunal is correct in law in holding that the amount of Rs. 2, 54.862, 19 represents income derived by the assessee in the course of trade

Summary

Issues:
Whether the profit earned by the assessee firm due to devaluation is taxable as business income or not.

Detailed Analysis:

The judgment delivered by the High Court of Kerala pertained to a reference made under the Income-tax Act, 1961, regarding the taxability of a profit of Rs. 2,54,862 earned by an assessee firm as a result of devaluation. The firm, engaged in exporting cashew kernels to foreign countries, earned this profit due to the devaluation of Indian currency, resulting in an appreciation in the exchange value of the price in dollars. The Income-tax Officer treated this profit as business income of the assessee, which was upheld in appeal and second appeal, leading to the reference to the High Court.

The primary contention of the assessee was that the profit arising from devaluation was of a casual nature and not taxable. However, the court held that the profit was earned during the course of trade and constituted a trading profit as it directly related to the sale proceeds. The court cited a similar case before the Mysore High Court, emphasizing that profits arising directly in the course of business form part of trading profit and are taxable. The court differentiated this case from a Supreme Court ruling where a surplus due to devaluation was considered a capital accretion, highlighting the distinct nature of the present case where the profit was a result of trading goods at an appreciated value due to devaluation.

Ultimately, the High Court upheld the Tribunal's conclusion that the profit earned by the assessee was taxable as business income. The court answered the reference question in the affirmative, ruling in favor of the respondents and awarding costs to them. The judgment concluded by directing the forwarding of a copy to the Appellate Tribunal, Cochin Bench, as required by law.

In summary, the judgment clarified that profits arising directly from business activities, such as the appreciated value of goods sold due to devaluation, are considered trading profits and are taxable. The court distinguished this case from precedents involving capital accretions, affirming the taxability of the profit earned by the assessee firm.