Over Invoicing and Mis-Declaration are serious violations of Customs Laws related to exports, and they can result in significant legal and financial consequences for businesses involved in international trade. Here's a detailed look at these practices, their implications, and the relevant provisions under Customs Laws in India.
1. Over Invoicing
Over invoicing refers to the practice of declaring a higher value for goods than their actual market value in export transactions. This is often done to manipulate the customs process for illegal or fraudulent purposes, such as evading taxes or to claim higher export benefits.
Common Motives Behind Over Invoicing:
- Claiming Excess Export Incentives/Benefits: Exporters might over invoice their goods to claim higher benefits under various schemes like RODTEP (Remission of Duties and Taxes on Exported Products), ROSCTL (Rebate of State and Central Taxes and Levies), or other export incentives.
- Money Laundering: Over invoicing can be used as a method for transferring illegal money abroad by showing inflated export values and getting funds back into the country through fictitious transactions.
- Tax Evasion: By inflating the export value, exporters may avoid or reduce their tax liabilities, such as GST, customs duties, or other applicable taxes.
Key Features of Over Invoicing:
- Inflated Export Value: The declared invoice value of goods is higher than their actual market value.
- Misrepresentation of Goods: The exporter may misrepresent the goods’ nature or quantity to justify the inflated invoice value.
- Incorrect Payment of Export Duties/Taxes: This could involve the claim of benefits based on the higher value of goods, leading to the improper use of government schemes or the evasion of customs duties.
Consequences of Over Invoicing:
- Penalties and Fines: Customs authorities may impose significant penalties or fines if over invoicing is detected.
- Seizure of Goods: If goods are found to be misdeclared or the invoicing is found to be fraudulent, the goods may be seized by Customs.
- Loss of Export Benefits: Any export benefits claimed on over-invoiced goods may be withdrawn, and the exporter may be required to repay the excess incentives.
- Prosecution: Over invoicing is a violation of the Customs Act, and serious instances can lead to prosecution under relevant sections for fraud and misdeclaration.
2. Mis-Declaration for Exports
Mis-declaration involves providing incorrect or false information about the goods being exported. This could include errors or intentional misstatements related to the classification, valuation, quantity, or description of goods. It is often used to gain an unfair advantage, avoid certain taxes, or evade regulations.
Common Types of Mis-Declaration:
- Misclassification: Incorrectly declaring goods under a lower duty rate or under an incorrect HS Code to reduce the duty liability.
- Undervaluation: Declaring goods at a lower value than their actual market value, which reduces the duty and taxes payable.
- Incorrect Description of Goods: Declaring goods as something other than what they are, either to gain preferential treatment or to avoid regulatory checks.
- False Declaration of Origin: Declaring goods as originating from a country eligible for preferential duty treatment (like an FTA) when they actually do not meet the origin requirements.
Common Motives Behind Mis-Declaration:
- Duty Evasion: Mis-declaration can be used to avoid paying correct customs duties, taxes, or excise duties.
- FTAs and Preferential Treatment: Incorrectly declaring the origin of goods to benefit from Free Trade Agreements (FTAs) and receive duty exemptions.
- Compliance with Regulations: Some exporters mis-declare goods to avoid compliance with regulatory restrictions (e.g., non-compliance with export control regulations or safety standards).
Consequences of Mis-Declaration:
- Customs Penalties: The Customs Department may impose heavy fines, penalties, and interest on duties that were evaded due to mis-declaration.
- Seizure and Confiscation of Goods: Goods may be seized if mis-declaration is detected, especially if the mis-declaration involves prohibited or restricted items.
- Cancellation of Export Benefits: Any export incentives or subsidies received on the basis of mis-declared goods may be withdrawn.
- Criminal Prosecution: Under the Customs Act, mis-declaration may result in criminal action, and individuals involved could face imprisonment or heavy fines.
3. Relevant Provisions in the Customs Act, 1962
Several sections of the Customs Act, 1962 specifically address the issues of over invoicing and mis-declaration:
Section 12: Levy of Duty
- This section mandates the payment of customs duty on goods imported into or exported from India, based on their actual value, classification, and other applicable factors.
Section 14: Valuation of Goods
- This section outlines the basis for determining the transaction value of goods. In case of mis-declaration or undervaluation, this section provides the guidelines for determining the correct value for customs duty purposes.
Section 28: Demand of Duties and Penalty
- If over invoicing or mis-declaration is found after customs clearance, Section 28 empowers Customs to demand the payment of unpaid duties, including penalties for mis-declaration or undervaluation.
Section 28A: Notice for Recovery of Duty
- If Customs finds that goods were mis-declared, they can issue a Show Cause Notice (SCN), demanding the recovery of duties along with penalties for any misdeclaration or false invoicing.
Section 113: Penalty for Mis-Declaration
- This section specifically covers penalties for mis-declaration, including penalties for undervaluation, incorrect classification, and false declaration of origin or other goods-related details.
Section 114: Penalty for Failure to Declare Goods
- This section provides penalties for importers/exporters who fail to declare goods correctly or mis-declare their nature, description, or value.
Section 114A: Penalty for Short Payment of Duty
- In case of mis-declaration, over invoicing, or undervaluation leading to short payment of customs duties, this section allows for penalties equal to the amount of the short paid duty, with an additional penalty of up to 100% of the duty involved.
Section 115: Confiscation of Goods
- If goods are found to be involved in illegal transactions, including over invoicing or mis-declaration, Customs has the authority to confiscate the goods.
Section 116: Penalties for Misrepresentation or Suppression of Facts
- Penalties are prescribed for cases of misrepresentation or suppression of facts related to exports or imports under this section.
Section 116A: Penalty for Over Invoicing
- While over invoicing is not explicitly mentioned in this section, the general penalty provisions for misrepresentation and suppression of facts can apply to over invoicing situations.
Section 142: Power to Arrest
- In cases where over invoicing or mis-declaration involves criminal activity, Customs authorities have the power to arrest individuals involved under Section 142.
4. Preventive Measures Against Over Invoicing and Mis-Declaration
- Proper Documentation: Ensure all export documentation is accurate and reflects the true value, classification, and description of goods.
- Audit and Compliance Checks: Conduct regular audits of export transactions to ensure that valuation, classification, and origin of goods are correctly declared.
- Consult Experts: Consult customs consultants or legal experts for guidance on complex customs rules, tariffs, and regulations.
- Use of Advance Rulings: Seek an advance ruling from the Authority for Advance Ruling (AAR) for clarity on the classification, valuation, and duty treatment of goods before filing export declarations.
5. Conclusion
Both over invoicing and mis-declaration are significant violations of Customs Laws, and businesses engaged in international trade must ensure that their declarations are accurate and compliant with the law. Violations of these practices not only harm the integrity of international trade but also expose businesses to heavy penalties, fines, and even criminal prosecution. Therefore, it's crucial for exporters to maintain proper records, follow the correct procedures, and consult experts to mitigate the risks of over invoicing and mis-declaration.
9911796707
