The ITAT Surat held that disallowance of business loss on sale ...

Business loss claim on sale of securities allowed. Assessee provided genuine evidence, AO failed to prove collusion.

Case Laws Income Tax

May 28, 2024

The ITAT Surat held that disallowance of business loss on sale of securities as LTCG in penny stocks was unjustified. The AO failed to provide evidence of collusive transactions or falsity in the assessee's documents. Relying on SHAILESH S. SHAH, suspicion alone cannot warrant additions. Default by the broker does not prove wrongdoing; other evidence like purchase details, source explanation, STT payment, and banking transactions must be considered. Without concrete evidence, no disallowance can be made. The addition by AO was deleted, and the assessee's appeal was allowed.

View Source

← Previous Next →

The ITAT Surat held that disallowance of business loss on sale ...

Business loss claim on sale of securities allowed. Assessee provided genuine evidence, AO failed to prove collusion.

Case Laws Income Tax

May 28, 2024

You may also like:

Disallowance of loss on sale of Government Securities - permissible business loss or not? - The Tribunal disagreed with the AO's presumption that the securities were not...

Correct head of income - Profit or loss derived from sale of land - Assessee has computed profit or loss derived from sale of land under the head ‘capital gains’ to...

Disallowance of mark to market losses - Nature of loss - allowable business loss or not? - The assessee is consistently following the method of accounting. Therefore,...

Forex loss - allowable business loss u/s 37(1) or not? - The assessee company has entered into transactions of buying and selling of forex and incurred a loss on the...

Bid-loss - Claim of business loss - assessee was explaining the principle followed by them, which results in bid loss. What the AO wanted was to give evidence that the...

Nature of loss - Speculative loss or normal business loss - Marked to market loss on hedging of the transaction - The Appellate Tribunal held that speculative...

Bad debts claimed u/s 36(2)(i) - Assessee debited ‘Amount written off paid against advance of land’ - As per accounting policy and general business practice any nature...

Disallowance of business loss - AO held that the intention of the assessee was only to set off the rental income against such business loss therefore, disallowed the...

Bad debts - Disallowance of deduction claimed in respect of notional interest taxed as income in earlier year, which was not realized by the appellant - the assessee is...

Loss on sale of land - ‘Business Loss’ or ‘Capital Loss’ - The present land transaction may be the first transaction of the assessee firm but the sister concern of the...

Unexplained cash credit u/s 68 r/w section 115BBE - Bogus purchase and sale - The assessee has recorded the entries of sales and purchase in its books of account and has...

Sale tax paid on sales return - allegation of bogus sales - allowable business loss - When the factum of sales return has been proved in favour of the assessee and...

Nature of loss - capital loss or business loss - company in liquidation - assesssee claimed the same as business loss - Tribunal allowed the same as capital loss -...

Speculative or non speculative business - treatment of “high sea sale” - when the goods are not taken by the delivery the entire issue is treated as speculative...

Disallowance of commodity derivative loss - speculative loss or not - Assessee is engaged in one and only business of derivative trading in different commodity exchanges...

Quick Updates: