The Court held that the Commissioner (Appeals) could not have ...

Commissioner Appeals can't pass order based on quashed order. New facts emerged, should've remanded for fresh consideration.

Case Laws Customs

July 10, 2024

The Court held that the Commissioner (Appeals) could not have passed the impugned order as it relied upon an order which was quashed and set aside by the High Court. The High Court had previously held that if the Commissioner (Appeals) was satisfied that new facts emerged, he could not decide the matter himself and should have remanded it for fresh consideration. Consequently, the impugned order passed by the Commissioner (Appeals) was quashed, and it was held that the petitioners were entitled to exemption for additional customs duty for aluminum waste and scrap under the relevant notification.

View Source

← Previous Next →

The Court held that the Commissioner (Appeals) could not have ...

Commissioner Appeals can't pass order based on quashed order. New facts emerged, should've remanded for fresh consideration.

Case Laws Customs

July 10, 2024

You may also like:

The case involves timeliness of appeal filed u/s 85(3A) of Finance Act, 1994 before Commissioner (Appeals-II) and refund claim. The Appellate Tribunal found that the...

Power of commissioner (appeals) to remand back the case - There are no piece of evidence to take a contrary view to the finding of the first appellate authority as to...

Validity of remand order passed by the Commissioner (Appeals) - The tribunal found that the Commissioner (Appeals) erred in remanding the case without meeting specific...

Valuation of imported goods - Glass Chaton of various varieties - rejection of declared value - enhancement of value based on NIDB data - The order is set aside and...

Power of Remand - The order passed by the Commissioner (Appeals) remanding back the matter for fresh adjudication is set aside and the case is remanded back to the...

Right of department to file any appeal or cross-objections before the Commissioner (Appeals) against Refund order - the Department could neither have filed an appeal...

Jurisdiction - power of Commissioner (Appeals) to remand back the matter - case of Refund of Service Tax - it is settled that the Commissioner (Appeals) has power to...

Power of commissioner (appeals) to remand back the case - The order under challenge is not either of the one as is mentioned in sub clause (3) of Section 35A. It is...

Condonation of delay in filing appeal before Commissioner (Appeals) - Initially the appellant was advised to file a representation before the Chief Commissioner against...

Scope of the order pursuant to remand back of the matter - Refund of Excess Duty paid - The Ld. Commissioner (Appeals) has travelled beyond the remand order passed by...

The case involved an appeal dismissed due to the absence of a Board Resolution copy from the authorized signatory filing the appeal. The Appellate Tribunal held that as...

Introduction of the authority of Joint Commissioner (Appeals) - In order to reduce burden or bottleneck of small cases with small amount of disputes and demand from...

Penalty u/s 271(1)(c) - fresh assessment in the remand proceedings - AO not only maintained the earlier income but even the appeal instituted by the appellant against...

Jurisdiction of Commissioner (Appeals) - under section 85(4) of the Finance Act, 1994, the Commissioner (Appeals) would have power to remand a case to the adjudicating...

Valuation of imported goods - The Commissioner (Appeals) completely failed to advert to the crucial aspect that the importers had themselves accepted the enhanced value....

Quick Updates: