Provision for warranty expenses computed on basis of past ...

Warranty expenses based on formula allowed even without past history. Accrual system prevails over actual payment year.

Case Laws Income Tax

July 12, 2024

Provision for warranty expenses computed on basis of past experience and scientific basis is allowable. Assessee applied formula for provision though no past history was available. Claim based on formula was allowed in subsequent years. Assessee maintained accounts on accrual basis and claimed expenses were actually incurred in subsequent year. Allowability of expenses in year of payment cannot be allowed as accounts are maintained on mercantile system. Nature of expenses being business cannot be lost. Actual incurrence proves provision computed on formula is correct. Supreme Court held provision for warranty on sophisticated goods is deductible u/s 37 if defects existed. Assessee demonstrated defects occurred and rectified during warranty period. Impugned expenses to be allowed after verifying actual incurrence during unexpired warranty period.

View Source

← Previous Next →

Provision for warranty expenses computed on basis of past ...

Warranty expenses based on formula allowed even without past history. Accrual system prevails over actual payment year.

Case Laws Income Tax

July 12, 2024

You may also like:

Provision for warranty - Assessee has explained the basis for working of the provision for warranty based on past experience and it is not on adhoc basis - Claim of...

Liquidated damages provision was disallowed as it was based on unascertained liability without probability of outflow of resources. ITAT deleted addition, holding...

Provision for Warranty - The assessee had not proved the provision of warranty expenses based on any scientific method in such circumstances - Triple test was not passed...

Provision for warranty expenses - contingent liability - there has been no material placed before the AO to establish that the provision in the accounts for the warranty...

Disallowance being provision made for warranty expenses - The assessee’s warranty provision equally lack in the proper accounting / calculating factors and, therefore,...

The appellant provides warranty services to customers who purchased machines from its parent company, receiving commission on sales. The appellant made provisions in its...

Additional provision for warranty Claim - Tribunal allowed normal warranty, extended warranty, however denied additional provision for warranty on domestic sales claimed...

Disallowance for warranty expenses - assessee is entitled to change the method of accounting with respect to claim of warranty expenses from ‘actual basis’ to ‘provision...

Disallowance of provision of warranty - The provision made by the assessee was ascertained based on the actual expenses incurred on settlement of warranty schemes in...

Transfer pricing adjustment on export commission paid to related party disallowed based on assessee's own case demonstrating benefits and higher profitability. Royalty...

Business expenses claimed under the head of “Provision for Warranty Expenses” - addition u/s 37 - Assessee company has not committed any error in making provisions...

Deductible expenses u/s 37 - provisions for warranty claims - The Tribunal upheld the practice of making provisions for warranty based on a reasonable estimation method...

30% ad-hoc disallowance of travelling expenses being car charges, foreign travelling expenses and domestic travelling expenses - The Assessee argued that the expenses...

Method of computing profit rate - assessee's past history was available and there was no material difference in the facts pertaining to the relevant assessment year and...

Valuation by DVO - addition based on estimated cost disregarding actual cost as per books - applicability of section 142A before amendment - non-rejection of books - AO...

Quick Updates: