HC held that respondent Corporation cannot demand GST from ...

Corporation's Penalties for Guideline Breaches Not Subject to GST, Court Rules; No Supply of Goods/Services Found.

January 7, 2025

Case Laws GST HC

HC held that respondent Corporation cannot demand GST from petitioners on penalty imposed for non-attendance of leakage complaint as there was no "supply of goods/services" by Corporation to petitioners. To demand GST, it must be proved that there is "supply of goods/services" by person collecting tax to person from whom tax is recovered. Here, no service was supplied by Corporation to petitioners while imposing penalty. Amounts sought were not for tolerating an act but for not following terms of agreement/guidelines framed by Corporation as deterrent against future breach. Petition dismissed.

View Source

← Previous Next →

HC held that respondent Corporation cannot demand GST from ...

Corporation's Penalties for Guideline Breaches Not Subject to GST, Court Rules; No Supply of Goods/Services Found.

January 7, 2025

Case Laws GST HC

You may also like:

Classification of Supply - transfer (sale) of ongoing business / unit - supply of goods or supply of services or supply of goods services - The definition of services...

Classification of supplies - supply of goods or supply of services? - software licenses supplied by the applicant - the goods which are supplied by the applicant cannot...

Service Tax Demand - On "Business Support Service": The Tribunal found that the uplinking services provided to broadcasters fall within the ambit of "Business Support...

Classification of services - pure services or not - Architectural Consultancy Service provided by the applicant to Surat Municipal Corporation for construction of SMIMER...

Classification of services - rate of GST - services provided to Nagar Nigam (Local Authority) - services of electrical, lighting, earthing, fixation of junction boxes,...

Classification of services - Goods or service - No VAT may be payable on some goods under the state laws but that does not convert the Works Contract Service into a pure...

Classification of supply - Pure Supply of goods or a Pure Supply of Services - Composite Supply - The principal supply however is a supply of service as it is the...

Levy of IGST - Export of services or not - telecom services - Place of supply - international Inbound Roaming Services (IIR) and International Long Distance (ILD)...

Scope of supply - supply of goods or supply of services - printing text books, Lottery tickets, stationery items for State Government - All the activities as mentioned...

Classification of supply - supply of goods or supply of services - supply of food and beverages by the eating joints - the supply of food by the entity partially or...

The circular clarifies the place of supply for data hosting services provided by Indian service providers to overseas cloud computing service providers. It addresses...

Classification of supply - composite supply of services or not - health care services - if composite amount is not charged from the patient. and if the cost of medicines...

The applicant entered into an agreement with the Central Hospital, South Eastern Railway to provide catering services by running the in-house kitchen, for which the...

Exemption from tax for supply of selling space for advertisement in print media qualifies as pure service under Entry 3 of Exemption Notification. Supply does not...

Supply of goods on High Sea Sales - Supply of goods or supply of services - Supply of imported goods on High Sea Sales basis will not be treated as supply of "goods" -...

Quick Updates: