HC dismissed the review petition challenging pre-deposit ...

Pre-deposit Requirement Cannot Be Waived for Loss-making Unit; Review Petition Dismissed with Rs.10,000 Costs

February 6, 2025

Case Laws GST HC

HC dismissed the review petition challenging pre-deposit requirements with Rs.10,000/- costs. The petition failed on procedural and substantive grounds. The Advocate's certificate accompanying the review petition did not comply with Rule 23(iii) of Chapter IV of the Bombay HC Rules. The court rejected petitioner's argument that being a loss-making unit warranted waiver of 10% pre-deposit requirement. The court emphasized that extraordinary jurisdiction cannot be invoked merely to circumvent pre-deposit conditions. The review jurisdiction being limited in scope, and the petition essentially attempting to re-argue the matter, no grounds were established for exercising review powers.

View Source

← Previous

HC dismissed the review petition challenging pre-deposit ...

Pre-deposit Requirement Cannot Be Waived for Loss-making Unit; Review Petition Dismissed with Rs.10,000 Costs

February 6, 2025

Case Laws GST HC

You may also like:

HC addressed valuation dispute regarding exported Printed Circuit Boards where penalty was significantly increased from Rs.1,00,000 to Rs.1,00,00,000 in subsequent...

Petitioner pre-deposited Rs. 6,25,000/- as condition for filing appeal u/s 51 of TNVAT Act against Assessment Order dated 21.10.2010. After revised Assessment Order on...

The Jharkhand High Court granted permission for release of confiscated goods subject to a pre-deposit u/s 107 of the GST Act. The assessee was required to make a...

Maintainability of appeal - requirement of mandatory pre-deposit - after 6.8.2014 neither the Tribunal nor the Commissioner (Appeals) have the power to waive the...

Appellant failed to submit required documents within stipulated time for provisional duty assessment, contravening Customs (Provisional Duty Assessment) Regulations,...

Requirement of deposit of seventy-five per cent of the amount of award as a pre-condition for entertaining an application / appeal - While upholding the validity of...

The High Court held that petitioners are entitled to pay 10% of the disputed GST amount as a pre-condition for filing an appeal by debiting the amount available in the...

Waiver of pre-deposit - requirement u/s 129E - The case revolved around the appellant's failure to fulfill the mandatory pre-deposit requirement under section 129E of...

Power to waiver of mandatory pre-deposit - Section 129E does not empower the Tribunal or the Commissioner (Appeals) to waive the pre-deposit or to reduce the pre-deposit.

The appellant has not made the pre-deposit and even though time was given to the appellant to make the pre-deposit, the pre-deposit has not been made - In view of the...

Service tax recovery from foreign government agencies for statutory fees/licenses - Petitioner's declaration under SVLDRS rejected - HC held pre-deposit amount during...

Maintainability of appeal - appeal rejected as being defective for non-payment of the pre-deposit - the appeals filed by the instant petitioners u/s 107 of the CGST/BGST...

Seeking waiver of pre deposit - Clandestine Removal - The impugned demand is to the extent of Rs.12.50 Crores. The pre-deposit of 10% would come to Rs.1.25 crores which...

Refund claim of amount deposited during investigation - the appellant is entitled to refund with interest under Section 35 FF, for which no limitation is applicable. The...

Recovery of erroneous refund - amount paid by the appellant’s Chennai Unit towards the pre-deposit in connection with an appeal filed arising out of order in Tuticorin...

Quick Updates: