2000 (6) TMI 23 - HC - Income Tax

Summary

Issues:
- Allowance of deduction under section 80C of the Income-tax Act, 1961 for the contribution made for the purchase of National Savings Certificate.
- Interpretation of whether the contribution should come from income chargeable to tax in the previous year.

Analysis:
The case involved a dispute regarding the allowance of deduction under section 80C of the Income-tax Act, 1961 for a contribution made towards the purchase of a National Savings Certificate. The Appellate Tribunal allowed a deduction of Rs. 25,000, which was contested by the Revenue. The assessing and appellate authorities had initially refused the deduction, arguing that the purchase was not made from income earned during the previous year.

The Department interpreted the explanation provided by the assessee regarding the source of funds for the purchase as indicating that it did not come from income chargeable under the Act. However, the Tribunal disagreed, stating that section 80C allows deduction for sums paid in the previous year from income chargeable to tax, which could include savings from the income of the preceding year. The Tribunal found that the assessee had utilized income from the previous year for the purchase, making them eligible for the deduction.

The Revenue's counsel argued that the payment should strictly come from income chargeable to tax to qualify for exemption under section 80C. They cited a Division Bench decision emphasizing that the deduction can be granted only if the payment is made from income chargeable to tax. The court noted a decision by the Orissa High Court supporting this interpretation.

The respondent-assessee's counsel contended that the Tribunal had already established that the purchase was made from income of the previous year, rendering the legal question irrelevant in this case. The High Court agreed, stating that the Tribunal's decision was reasonable as the assessee had clearly stated that the National Savings Certificate was purchased from income earned in the previous year, which exceeded the amount invested in the certificate.

Ultimately, the High Court declined to answer the legal question raised by the Revenue, as the Tribunal's decision was found to be based on the fact that the purchase was made from income of the previous year. The income-tax reference was disposed of accordingly.