1981 (12) TMI 4 - HC - Income Tax

Summary

Issues: Valuation of unquoted shares of a private company based on balance-sheet dates.

The High Court of Madras addressed the issue of valuing unquoted shares of a private company for gift-tax assessment. The valuation method followed was the break-up value method, which involves considering the assets and liabilities of the company to determine the net worth and subsequently the value of individual shares. The shares in question were gifted between two balance-sheet dates, leading to a debate on which balance-sheet and figures should be taken into account. The figures of Rs. 107.34 and Rs. 134.82 per share were derived from the balance-sheets of the company as of March 31, 1970, and March 31, 1971, respectively. The Gift-tax Officer valued the shares at Rs. 134.82 per share based on the balance-sheet as of March 31, 1971, close to the gift date. However, the Tribunal disagreed and favored using the balance-sheet as of March 31, 1970, as it was the last published balance-sheet before the gift date. The Tribunal also made allowances for dividends declared post-March 31, 1970, but before the gift date of March 22, 1971. The Department argued that subsequent balance-sheets, like the one from March 31, 1971, should be considered for valuation due to their proximity to the gift date. The court referred to a similar case where they directed the Tribunal to consider the balance-sheet post the gift date for valuation. Consequently, the court held that the Tribunal erred in disregarding the balance-sheet as of March 31, 1971, and emphasized the importance of considering the assets and liabilities close to the gift date for valuation. While not providing the exact valuation figures, the court clarified that the correct valuation should be determined by the Tribunal based on the principles outlined in the judgment. The court answered the reference accordingly, without costs.