1996 (4) TMI 531 - SC - Indian Laws

Summary

Issues: Interpretation of settlement deed as a will

Analysis:
The judgment involves a dispute regarding the interpretation of a settlement deed, Ex. B-1, which was considered by the Division Bench to be a will. The key issue is whether the document confers an interest in the property immediately or only upon the demise of the settlor. The settlement deed executed by Ch. Seshamma in favor of her daughter Vimalavathy was the subject of contention. The settlement deed explicitly mentioned the properties to be transferred to Vimalavathy after the demise of the settlor. The court analyzed the language of the document and the intentions of the executant to determine if it created an irrevocable interest in the property. The court emphasized that the nomenclature of the document is not conclusive, and the overall recitals and intentions of the parties are crucial in determining the nature of the document.

The settlement deed clearly outlined that the properties mentioned were to be enjoyed by Vimalavathy with absolute rights after the demise of the settlor. The court noted that the document created a life interest for the settlor and vested remainder in favor of Vimalavathy. It was established that the settlor had divested herself of the title to the property, creating a life estate for her enjoyment during her lifetime, with the property devolving to Vimalavathy with absolute rights upon the settlor's demise. The court concluded that the document should be construed as a settlement deed rather than a will, as it created an interest in praesenti in favor of Vimalavathy.

The trial court and the learned single judge had correctly dismissed the claim based on the interpretation of the settlement deed. The Division Bench's decision to decree the suit in favor of Hymavathy was deemed incorrect in law. Consequently, the Supreme Court allowed the appeal, confirming the decree of the trial court. The judgment highlights the importance of carefully analyzing the language and intentions of legal documents to determine the nature of property rights created therein.