9911796707
|
Home
Issues involved: Eligibility of the assessee for deduction u/s 80(1A)(4) for infrastructure facility set up by Cochin Port Trust for assessment year 2003.
The judgment addresses the question of whether the Tribunal was justified in declaring the eligibility of the assessee for deduction under Section 80(1A)(4) for an infrastructure facility set up by the Cochin Port Trust. The assessee had entered into an agreement with the Port Trust for erecting and maintaining storage tanks and other facilities for liquid cargo. The plant became operational within two years, but the assessee could not claim the deduction initially due to a proviso in Section 80(1A) 4(i)(b) which required transfer of the facility to the government or authority. However, this condition was later amended, removing the transfer requirement. The Revenue contended that the exemption was only available for new infrastructure facilities set up after the amendment, while the Assessee argued that the benefit applied from the year of eligibility, including existing facilities. The Court found that the word "new" in the provision did not restrict existing facilities from eligibility, as long as they were operational by a certain date. Therefore, the Court upheld the Tribunal's decision, allowing the assessee's deduction claim. In analyzing the provisions of Section 80(1A), the Court determined that the Department's argument that only new infrastructure facilities set up after the 2002 amendment were eligible for deduction was not valid. The Court clarified that the word "new" in the provision did not exclude existing facilities, as long as they met the operational criteria. The Court emphasized that the assessee's facility, set up in 1998, qualified as an infrastructure facility for the deduction. Therefore, the Court rejected the Revenue's argument and upheld the Tribunal's decision, allowing the assessee's claim for deduction under Section 80(1A)(4) for the infrastructure facility set up by the Cochin Port Trust. The Court's decision in this case clarifies the eligibility criteria for deduction under Section 80(1A)(4) for infrastructure facilities. The Court held that existing infrastructure facilities, operational by a certain date, are eligible for the deduction, even if there is no provision for transfer of the facility to the government or authority. The Court emphasized that the word "new" in the provision does not preclude existing facilities from claiming the deduction. Therefore, the Court upheld the Tribunal's decision and dismissed the Revenue's appeal, allowing the assessee's claim for deduction for the infrastructure facility set up by the Cochin Port Trust.
|
