9911796707
|
Home
Issues: Interpretation of Wealth-tax Act provisions regarding valuation of property for assessment years prior to 1976-77.
In this judgment by the Appellate Tribunal ITAT CHANDIGARH, the issue revolved around the interpretation of provisions of section 7(4) of the Wealth-tax Act for assessment years prior to 1976-77. The assessee, an individual, claimed that the value of a house should be taken as on 31st March, 1977, based on section 7(4) of the Act. The WTO and AAC rejected this claim, stating that section 7(4) was effective only from 1st April, 1976, and not applicable to the assessment year in question. The counsel for the assessee argued that section 7(4) is procedural and should apply to pending proceedings, even for earlier years, as it benefits the assessee. Reference was made to a Tribunal judgment supporting this view. The Tribunal analyzed whether section 7(4) could be applied to assessments pending at the time of its insertion, even for years before 1976-77. It was observed that the section does not specify applicability from a particular assessment year, indicating its procedural nature. Citing a Bombay High Court case, it was established that section 7 is a machinery provision, making subsection (4) procedural. The Tribunal emphasized that if there are two possible interpretations of a taxing statute, the one favoring the assessee should be adopted. It was concluded that the authorities erred in denying the benefit of section 7(4) to the assessee and directed the WTO to recompute the net wealth considering the applicability of section 7(4) to the case. The judgment highlighted that section 7(4) provides an option for the assessee to include the value of the asset in their net wealth based on specific conditions related to the ownership and use of the house. It emphasized that any exemption or relief granted by Parliament should not be diluted by administrative authorities or courts based on perceived ambiguities. The Tribunal set aside the orders of the lower authorities and allowed the appeal, directing the re-computation of the assessee's net wealth considering the applicability of section 7(4) of the Wealth-tax Act.
|
