9911796707
|
Home
Issues:
1. Whether the deceased's share in the goodwill of the firm is exigible to estate duty. 2. Whether the revaluation of the closing stock of the firm on the retirement of the deceased was justified. Detailed Analysis: 1. The judgment dealt with the issue of whether the deceased's share in the goodwill of the firm was subject to estate duty. The deceased was a partner in a firm, and upon his retirement, the Assessing Officer determined the value of his share in the goodwill and included it for estate duty calculation. The accountable person challenged this decision, arguing that as the deceased was not a partner at the time of his death, his share in the goodwill should not be subject to estate duty. The Tribunal examined relevant legal principles, including provisions of the Partnership Act and previous court decisions. It was established that goodwill is considered an asset of the firm, and a retiring partner retains rights to it unless specifically extinguished. The Tribunal found that in this case, the deceased's right to the goodwill did not cease upon retirement, and therefore, his share in the goodwill was deemed as passing on his death, justifying its inclusion for estate duty. 2. The second issue addressed in the judgment was the revaluation of the closing stock of the firm on the retirement of the deceased partner. The Assessing Officer revalued the closing stock at market price, leading to an additional amount being brought to charge for estate duty calculation. The accountable person contested this revaluation, claiming there was no basis for the adjustment. The Tribunal referred to established legal precedents that require the valuation of closing stock at market price upon a partner's retirement. Citing relevant decisions of the jurisdictional High Court, the Tribunal upheld the revaluation of the closing stock as justified. It was emphasized that the retirement of a partner is considered as dissolution of the firm, warranting the revaluation of assets. Consequently, the Tribunal declined to interfere with the lower authorities' decision regarding the revaluation of the closing stock. In conclusion, the Tribunal dismissed the appeal of the accountable person, affirming the inclusion of the deceased's share in the goodwill for estate duty and upholding the revaluation of the closing stock upon the deceased partner's retirement.
|
