Revenue Appeal against one order of Commissioner Appeal whereas ...

Appeal Dismissed to Avoid Inconsistent Orders on Similar Issues; Reference to Res Judicata Principle Explained.

July 17, 2019

Case Laws Central Excise AT

Revenue Appeal against one order of Commissioner Appeal whereas Commission has decided two cases simultaneously on similar issues - Though res judicata may not strictly apply to the orders passed by the Commissioner (Appeals), but the aid of such principles can be taken. In the present case if this appeal is allowed, two inconsistent orders will come into existence. The present appeal, therefore, is liable to be dismissed for this reason.

View Source

← Previous Next →

Revenue Appeal against one order of Commissioner Appeal whereas ...

Appeal Dismissed to Avoid Inconsistent Orders on Similar Issues; Reference to Res Judicata Principle Explained.

July 17, 2019

Case Laws Central Excise AT

You may also like:

CIT(Appeals) dismissed assessee's appeal for non-prosecution despite assessee being afforded multiple opportunities to participate. However, CIT(Appeals) failed to...

The High Court held that the appeals against orders in proceedings for execution or enforcement of arbitral awards are not maintainable. The doctrine of res judicata or...

Restoration of appeal - Dismissed by way of remand - Revenue's argument that the appeals are not dismissed and have been remanded with all issues open accepted and...

Validity of order of ITAT allowing Applications filed u/s 254(2) - Rectification versus Review of order - TP Adjustment - The High court observed that the ITAT had...

Rejection of appeal as not maintainable - Appeal-able order - Filing of appeal before the Adjudication order - The expression 'order' used in sub-section (3) can in...

Section 253 of the Income Tax Act governs appeals to the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) against orders passed by tax authorities. The proposed amendment aims to...

The ITAT Gauhati Bench jurisdiction issue was raised concerning an appeal filed under improper jurisdiction. The assessee's address was consistently in Kolkata, with no...

Principle of res judicata – Constructive res judicata - if any issue or matter decided by the Court or Authority not having jurisdiction the principle of res judicata...

HC partially set aside assessment order concerning disputed "Security Wages" treatment, finding procedural deficiency as this issue was not specifically mentioned in...

The central issue revolves around the maintainability of a single appeal filed by the Revenue against multiple Bills of Entry. As per Rule 6(A) of the CESTAT Procedure...

Restoration of cross objection appeal - Dismissal of appeal of the revenue on low tax effect - consequently cross objections of the assessee were also dismissed - the...

CBDT clarifies that orders under section 201 of Income Tax Act are not exempt from e-Appeals Scheme 2023, even when made pursuant to section 133A actions. These orders...

Condonation of delay in filing appeal - Or the appeal was filed within the time - Once the appellant had indicated in ST-IV form that the order was received by the...

Invocation of extraordinary writ jurisdiction - petitioner not entitled to exclusion of time taken in writ proceedings from limitation period for filing appeal. Abuse of...

Maintainability of appeal - appeal dismissed on the ground of time limitation - non-submission of the certified copy. - Despite discrepancies raised by the respondent...

Quick Updates: