High Court rejected petitioner's writ petition challenging ...

Dismissing refund plea, Court upholds reasoned order; directs statutory appeal route over writ jurisdiction.

Case Laws GST

August 20, 2024

High Court rejected petitioner's writ petition challenging refund rejection order, observing that respondent authority had passed reasoned order after considering petitioner's reply and deficiencies in refund application. Court held that petitioner ought to have availed statutory appeal remedy instead of directly approaching Court. Under Article 226, High Court's jurisdiction in certiorari is supervisory, limited to correcting errors of jurisdiction or natural justice violations, not re-appreciating evidence. Appellate forum offers wider canvas than writ jurisdiction. Petition dismissed, with liberty to pursue statutory appeal.

View Source

← Previous Next →

High Court rejected petitioner's writ petition challenging ...

Dismissing refund plea, Court upholds reasoned order; directs statutory appeal route over writ jurisdiction.

Case Laws GST

August 20, 2024

You may also like:

The case involved a dispute over the writ jurisdiction of the High Court post privatization of (AIL) by a private corporate entity. - Erstwhile Public sector undertaking...

Maintainability of appeal against order under CGST/SGST Act adjudication on refund application dismissed. Appellant had option to pay amounts demanded or contest seizure...

Petition maintainability hinges on alternative remedy availability. Excess tax refund due to ignorance and legal ambiguity. Supreme Court ruled that purely legal...

Conviction u/ss 420, 467, 468, 120B of the IPC and Section 5(2) and 5(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. Petitioner worked as Appraiser in Customs office....

Invocation of extraordinary writ jurisdiction - petitioner not entitled to exclusion of time taken in writ proceedings from limitation period for filing appeal. Abuse of...

Refund of duty paid - filing of refund claim before the wrong jurisdiction - if the adjudicating authority was of the view that the appellant has not filed refund claim...

Refund of duty paid - filing of refund claim before the wrong jurisdiction - if the adjudicating authority was of the view that the appellant has not filed refund claim...

The High Court held that the petitioners have the option to file writ petitions challenging the orders of the Revisionary Authority either before the High Court within...

Refund of IGST - Zero Rated Supplies - it appears that the writ-applicant had claimed higher duty drawback - it is evident that the petitioner has claimed drawback of...

The ITAT Gauhati Bench jurisdiction issue was raised concerning an appeal filed under improper jurisdiction. The assessee's address was consistently in Kolkata, with no...

Refund of Service Tax - time limitation - Exercise of power u/s 142(3) of GST Act for refund of service tax - The case involves the rejection of a refund claim by the...

Alternative remedy of appeal - writ jurisdiction will be exercised only in cases of certain specific exceptions and particularly (a) lack of jurisdiction, (b) violation...

Service tax refund claim filed beyond statutory limitation period cannot be entertained. Refund application must be filed within one year from relevant date as per...

Refund of excess tax paid - rejection on the ground of time limitation - only under specific circumstances like “unconstitutionality, illegal levy, mistake of law’’...

Demand of GST - The High court noted that the return of documents raised a disputed question of fact, which could not be decided in the writ jurisdiction without further...

Quick Updates: