The Tribunal's order exonerating assessees from customs duty and ...

Tribunal's selective reliance on statements led to inconsistent order; must re-evaluate all facts for reasoned conclusion. Agency's penalty upheld; remanded for fresh adjudication.

Case Laws Customs

July 18, 2024

The Tribunal's order exonerating assessees from customs duty and penalty for undervaluation during import displayed inconsistency. It selectively relied on statements of Rakesh Magoo and John Miranda without holistic consideration. The Tribunal must re-evaluate all facts and evidence to reach a reasoned conclusion as the final fact-finding authority. The clearing agency's penalty was upheld. The matter concerning Rakesh Magoo and John Miranda was remanded to the Tribunal for fresh adjudication per law. Appeals by revenue and assessees were allowed.

View Source

← Previous Next →

The Tribunal's order exonerating assessees from customs duty and ...

Tribunal's selective reliance on statements led to inconsistent order; must re-evaluate all facts for reasoned conclusion. Agency's penalty upheld; remanded for fresh adjudication.

Case Laws Customs

July 18, 2024

You may also like:

Recording of wrong facts & reasoning by Tribunal - Tribunal did not correctly appreciate as to what AO and CIT (A) held and what was their reasoning which led to their...

Estimation of income - Bogus purchases - Reliance on retracted statement - The ITAT, after reviewing the case, noted discrepancies in the reliance on these statements...

Clandestine Removal - Retraction of statements - Statements of various persons stand recorded. No doubt the outcome of cross examination has to be given due importance...

Levy of Penalty - retracted statement - the admissibility of the statement recorded under Section 108 of the Act from the appellant on 11.03.1998, was considered by the...

Addition u/s 68 - receipt of share application money - reliance on statement of third parties - The statements of third parties i.e. two angadias relied upon by the ld....

Valuation - Reliance on the statement made before the customs officers - recording of statement u/s 108 - Certainly a statement recorded under duress or coercion cannot...

Additions against Over-invoicing of Purchases - The Tribunal found that the AO's selective reliance on pieces of evidence without considering the entirety of the...

Smuggling - Gold of foreign origin - Absolute Confiscation - town seizure - reliability of statements/retraction of statements - The tribunal highlighted inconsistencies...

LTCG - Deduction towards the ‘Cost of Improvement’ - The authorities have blown hot & cold in disallowing the expenditure. The selective reading of the sale agreement...

Clandestine Removal - statements recorded by Revenue - The Commissioner has clearly ignored this findings and come to a difference conclusion. While doing so he is...

Addition u/s 68 - Unexplained cash deposits - statement of the assessee admitting the income at the time of survey - subsequent retraction made by assessee - it is not...

Valuation of imported goods - stamping foils - rejection of declared value - The tribunal found that the department's reliance on proforma invoices for A-grade goods was...

Validity of reassessment proceedings challenged - capital gain on co-owned land sale - reassessment based on DVO report alleging suppression of lower valuation - reasons...

Addition u/s 69A - cash loans given by the assessee as unexplained - decoding of the entries in the seized materials - The tribunal found that the assessing officer's...

Addition based on voluntary disclosure made by the key person of the assesse group during the course of search which has subsequently been retracted - The statement...

Quick Updates: